The model assumes that although the amount of fourth dimension an private spends inwards a specific stage varies, everyone has to achieve the same stage-specific tasks inwards monastic enjoin to displace through the alter procedure (Prochaska & Prochaska, 2009). There is an unofficial 6th stage that is variously called "relapse," "recycling," or "slipping" inwards which an private reverts to quondam behaviors. Examples include having a beer later on a menses of sobriety, or smoking a cigarette a twelvemonth later on quitting. Slipping is so mutual that it is considered normal. Social Workers are encouraged to live honest amongst clients nigh the likelihood of backsliding or reverting to quondam behaviors 1 time the alter procedure has started, non because nosotros hold off our clients to fail, but because it normalizes the experience as well as takes away some of sense of failure as well as shame.
Although the "Stages of Change" model was identified as well as developed during a study of smoking cessation (Prochaska & DiClemente, 1983), the model has been applied to as well as studied amongst numerous bio-psycho-social problems, including domestic violence, HIV prevention, as well as kid abuse (Prochaska & Prochaska, 2009). The "stages of change" model is 1 ingredient of the "Transtheoretical model of conduct change" (Prochaska & DiClemente, 1983). It is called the "transtheoretical model" because it integrates fundamental constructs from other theories. The TTM describes stages of change, the Process of Change, as well as ways to stair out change. In today's podcast, I'm going to focus on the Stages of Change. If you lot are interested inwards learning to a greater extent than nigh the broader Transtheoretial Model, at that topographic point are dozens of resources online as well as inwards print. The University of Rhode Island's Cancer Prevention Research Center website has a clear as well as concise overview of the TTM: https://web.uri.edu/cprc/detailed-overview/. If you lot are looking for a social work-specific application of the TTM, at that topographic point is an first-class chapter inwards the
The purpose of this podcast is to render a brief overview of the 5 stages of alter as well as what intervention approaches are most appropriate at each stage of change. I drew on a issue of resources inwards the training of this podcast, including a chapter on the stages of alter as well as motivational interviewing yesteryear DiClemente & Velasquez inwards Miller as well as Rollnick's 2nd edition of their book, Motivational Interviewing (Miller & Rollnick, 2002) [note: Miller & Rollnick published a link to the podcast episode amongst Mary Velasquez nigh the changes to the 3rd edition]; Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 2002 article yesteryear Norcross as well as Prochaska (2002) from the Harvard Mental Health Letter called "Using the Stages of Change;" as well as the chapter yesteryear Prochaska as well as Prochaska (2009) inwards the 2nd edition of the Social Workers' Desk Reference that I but mentioned. All of these references tin live found on the podcast website at http://socialworkpodcast.com/.
In today's podcast I'll beak nigh how to figure out what stage someone is in, as well as seat a duo of interventions that are most effective for the soul inwards that stage. I'm non going to move into swell special nigh interventions because at that topographic point is a major handling approach called Motivational Interviewing that addresses dozens of intervention techniques. Along the way I'll render examples of things that social workers tin say to people inwards dissimilar stages of change. I've drawn most of my examples from situations other than addictions. I've done this because the Stages of Change model was developed out of addictions inquiry as well as at that topographic point are a lot of examples amongst addictions. Since the Stages of Change is applicable to behaviors other than addictions, I wanted to focus on some of those examples. I destination the podcast amongst a brief critique of the model.
Download MP3 [35:29]
Transcript
Precontemplation
Characteristics
People inwards precontemplation produce non watch their behaviors as a occupation as well as so watch no demand to change. This is sometimes called the "ignorance is bliss" stage. Clients inwards the precontemplation stage receive got traditionally been thought of as "resistant to change." You mightiness live thinking, "well, if someone doesn't watch their behaviors as a occupation as well as are non interested inwards changing, as well as so why would I demand to know how to piece of work amongst them – later on all, they are non probable to live inwards treatment." Although many people inwards precontemplation will, yesteryear definition, never introduce for treatment, inquiry has found that betwixt 50 – 60% of clients are inwards the stage of Precontemplation, which way they don't watch a occupation as well as so watch no demand to alter their behaviors. These include whatever customer who is pressured or coerced into services. Examples mightiness include the woman raise whose kid has been removed yesteryear the state; because it was her partner who abused the kid as well as non her, she doesn't watch how her behaviors would demand to change. However the State, as well as maybe others, watch her parenting as neglectful as well as non adequate to justify returning the kid to her care. Another instance is the kid who is brought for services yesteryear a raise because of problems inwards schoolhouse or at home; the kid mightiness watch that everyone else has a occupation – the teachers, the other kids, or fifty-fifty the parents. Other examples include clients who inwards handling because they were court-ordered, required yesteryear employers, or fifty-fifty yesteryear their partners. In all of these situations, at that topographic point is someone else who recognizes a occupation as well as has the powerfulness to brand the soul come inwards handling against their will. Norcross as well as Prochaska (2002) telephone outcry upwardly these clients "uninformed."Now, it is possible that these clients tried changing their behaviors inwards the yesteryear but were unsuccessful. Because the alter didn't piece of work or didn't stick inwards the past, they at 1 time watch alter as unrealistic or impossible as well as so non worth pursuing. Norcross as well as Prochaska (2002) telephone outcry upwardly these clients "underinformed." Examples mightiness include people who receive got tried to laissez passer upwardly smoking or drinking, people who receive got tried to exit abusive relationships, youth who receive got tried as well as failed to exit gangs, or fifty-fifty receive got failed to live successful at school.
So, the grouping of people who receive got never seen their behaviors as problems are considered "uninformed," as well as the grouping of people who receive got seen their behaviors as problematic inwards the yesteryear but are non currently interested inwards changing are called "underinformed." Neither grouping is interested inwards changing their electrical current behaviors.
Assessment
Norcross as well as Prochaska (2002) suggest assessing precontemplation yesteryear call for if the soul is considering making a alter inwards the adjacent vi months. If they concur to statements like, "I approximate I receive got faults, but there's zilch that I really demand to change" as well as "As far as I'm concerned, I don't receive got whatever problems that demand changing," as well as so they are inwards precontemplation. Prochaska as well as Prochaska (2009) regime notation that people inwards precontemplation AND maintenance believe that their behaviors produce non demand changing, but for rattling dissimilar reasons. So, it is of import to detect out why. The raise who says, "Yeah, I'm non perfect, but I'm no worse than anyone else, so why should I change?" is telling you lot that at that topographic point is no problem, as well as so no argue to change. This raise is inwards Precontemplation. In contrast, the raise who says, "Yeah, I'm non perfect, but I'm so much improve than I used to live as well as I'm really trying difficult non to autumn dorsum into my quondam ways of behaving" is telling you lot that he or she changed the problematic conduct as well as is trying to maintain it. This raise is inwards maintenance. If the divergence betwixt the 2 stages is a lilliputian confusing, no worries; it volition brand to a greater extent than sense yesteryear the fourth dimension I've finished the podcast. Just remember, at that topographic point are only 2 stages inwards which someone doesn't watch a problem: precontemplation as well as maintenance. In the other stages, contemplation, training as well as action, the soul sees a problem.Intervention
Clinicians receive got to tailor their interventions to tally the clients stage of change. For people inwards precontemplation inquiry has found that it tin live helpful to increase awareness nigh the problem. For a raise involved inwards kid welfare, the mere presence of protective services tin sometimes live plenty to increase awareness (Prochaska & Prochaska, 2009). Another intervention is to displace people emotionally. I ran a grouping for parents trying to reunify amongst their children who had been removed yesteryear protective services. One of the inaugural off assignments asked parents to write nigh the abuse or neglect from the child's perspective. This assignment was often rattling emotional as well as for many parents helped to displace them from a seat of beingness defensive nigh what they had done (or non done) to a seat of feeling really deplorable as well as remorseful. The emotional shift was fundamental inwards getting them to displace towards permanent alter inwards their parenting behaviors because they were able to admit a problem. Prochaska as well as Prochaska (2009) lift 3 other interventions that tin live used amongst precontemplators, including discussing the benefits of changing, encouraging the private to aspect at the consequences of what is happening now, as well as pointing out discrepancies betwixt the way the private would similar to live as well as the way they are.
So, let's say you lot produce all of this as well as your customer starts proverb things like, "yeah, I approximate that's a problem," or "I'm certain it would live improve if I didn't produce that," as well as so they receive got moved out of Precontemplation as well as are inwards stage 2 – contemplation.
Contemplation
Characteristics
The 2nd stage is called contemplation. In this stage, people recognize a occupation as well as are contemplating a change, but haven't yet committed to changing. For example, you lot want to lose weight as well as receive got looked into joining a gym but haven't yet signed up. People inwards contemplation are sitting on the struggle – constituent of them wants to change, but an every bit compelling constituent of them wants to rest the same. When you lot are sitting on the fence, nosotros say you lot are ambivalent nigh change. The contemplation stage is all nigh ambivalence. Prochaska as well as Prochaska (2009) regime notation that people tin rest inwards contemplation for a rattling long time. Change is tough. It is difficult to accept that inaugural off step. Chronic contemplators pass lots of fourth dimension thinking as well as non much fourth dimension doing. This is inwards constituent because "contemplators struggle to empathize their problem, to watch its causes, as well as to think nigh possible solutions" (DiClemente & Velasquez, 2002, p. 208).Assessment
You tin assess for contemplation yesteryear listening for statements like, "I know I receive got a problem, but I'm non really certain I want to produce anything nigh it." or "I'm non really certain what I tin produce nigh it." For example, a raise inwards the kid welfare organization mightiness say something like, "I know I tin produce improve yesteryear my kids, but I'm non really certain how." Once you've established that your customer is ambivalent, as well as so you lot tin determine what types of interventions are most appropriate.Intervention
The most of import thing to retrieve nigh intervening amongst someone inwards contemplation is that they are evaluating the pros as well as cons of change, but haven't yet decided to change. If you lot start making suggestions nigh how to change, the constituent of your customer that wants things to rest the same volition convey upwardly all of the reasons why alter is non possible. The finally thing you lot want to produce is receive got your customer beak themselves into non changing their dysfunctional behaviors. Miller as well as Rollnick (2002) telephone outcry upwardly the social worker's instinct to create the province of affairs the "righting reflex." So, how produce you lot beak amongst your customer so that they beak themselves into change? Prochaska as well as Prochaska (2009) suggest a issue of interventions including: 1) talking amongst your customer nigh the pros as well as cons of changing, also called the Decisional Balance technique; 2) Pointing out the discrepancy betwixt how your customer would similar to live as well as how they are, also known as Developing Discrepancy; and; 3) Instilling hope.Pros as well as cons: For the raise involved amongst kid welfare, you lot tin ask, "What are the benefits of changing your approach to parenting? What problems produce you lot watch amongst changing?" Your customer mightiness answer yesteryear saying, "I volition acquire my kids dorsum as well as kid welfare volition live out of my life," as well as "My kids only answer to spanking. I've tried fourth dimension out as well as it doesn't work, so I'm never going to live able to command my kids without beingness able to spank them." You also want to explore the pros as well as cons of maintaining the condition quo, also known as staying the same. You tin ask, "What reasons tin you lot come upwardly up amongst for non changing your parenting style? What are the downsides of keeping your parenting vogue the same?"
Developing discrepancy: You tin human face clients inwards this stage as well as hold off to receive got some impact. But, you lot receive got to focus on the discrepancy betwixt how they would similar to live as well as how they are. For example, you lot tin say to the raise involved amongst kid welfare, "You say that getting your kids dorsum is your #1 priority, but you've missed the finally 2 supervised visitations. Since actions speak louder than words, you're telling me that beingness amongst your kids is non your inaugural off priority." Now, that mightiness good harsh, but it points out the discrepancy betwixt the way the raise wants to live as well as the way they are. Your customer is non probable to live motivated to alter if they don't watch a divergence betwixt how they would similar to live as well as how they are. Another way of developing discrepancy is yesteryear providing your customer amongst pedagogy nigh how things could be, such as books or videos that illustrate novel behaviors. This sort of data is useless inwards Precontemplation because people don't watch a problem, but it industrial plant good inwards contemplation because they've partially bought into the thought that they want to change, but are non certain how.
Instilling hope: This is essential because people inwards contemplation receive got a vox within saying, "change is as good hard, it is non worth it, as bad as things are at 1 time it is easier than changing..." When you lot instill promise that your customer tin change, it supports the vox inwards your customer that says, "I don't similar how things are going, I want to change."
Preparation
Characteristics
The 3rd stage is called preparation. In this stage, people receive got decided to alter their dysfunctional behaviors within a month. People inwards training receive got taken lilliputian steps towards changing their conduct – they are "testing the waters." Those lilliputian steps mightiness receive got failed, or they mightiness receive got worked, but they receive got non resulted inwards the sort of conduct alter that the customer wants. For example, you lot want to lose weight, receive got said no to desert for the finally few months as well as fifty-fifty dusted off a workout tape. But you lot haven't lost whatever weight, don't receive got a comprehensive plan, as well as detect yourself to a greater extent than often than non engaged inwards the quondam behaviors, fifty-fifty though you lot don't want to.Assessment
When you lot assess for preparation, you lot want to heed for statements like, "I really want to alter because..." as well as "I wishing I could but figure out how to..." Prochaska as well as Prochaska (2009) suggest that a raise involved inwards the kid welfare organization mightiness betoken training yesteryear making statements like, "I receive got questions for my caseworker nigh how to raise differently," as well as "If I don't change, I'll never live the raise I want to be." Because your customer has already taken pocket-sized steps towards change, but hasn't been successful, you lot want to detect out how much back upwardly he or she has to brand the change, as well as if he or she has the skills needed to brand the change. For example, your customer wants to halt spanking her children but lacks the social back upwardly to produce that. Her friends as well as theater unit of measurement all spank as well as believe it is an appropriate intervention. When mom is non some they spank her kids. This mom has no back upwardly to raise differently. Furthermore, because she has no examples of how to bailiwick without spanking, she lacks the skills to follow through. For example, when you lot inquire how she mightiness bailiwick her kid without spanking, she comes upwardly short.Intervention
Prochaska as well as Prochaska (2009) suggest iv interventions for people inwards preparation: Encourage your client's commitment to change; back upwardly self-efficacy; generate a innovation as well as laid activeness goals.You tin encourage your kid welfare customer yesteryear proverb something like, "Your determination to alter how you lot raise tells me that you lot are dedicated to non only getting your kids back, but also to strengthening your theater unit of measurement to preclude futurity abuse as well as neglect."
When you lot generate a innovation as well as laid activeness goals you lot want to brand certain your setting upwardly your customer for success. If you lot receive got identified deficits inwards supports as well as skills, an appropriate innovation would live to found these as constituent of the goals for change. You don't want to laid upwardly your customer amongst unreasonable expectations for finding friends as well as theater unit of measurement who volition back upwardly their novel behaviors or else they volition displace away from wanting to change. The same is truthful for novel skills. You tin laid upwardly pocket-sized as well as attainable conduct goals for your in-office services so that at the destination of every session they experience similar they receive got accomplished something as well as are 1 pace closer to their goal. Social workers should live aware, though, that but because a customer is preparing to brand change, doesn't hateful that they are willing to participate inwards the computer program that the social worker has identified for the client. I mightiness live prepared to bring together a gym lose weight, but as a human inwards my belatedly 30s, I won't bring together Curves or Lady Fitness. So, it is of import non to confuse willingness to alter amongst an automatic buy-in of existing programs or services.
Action
Characteristics
The quaternary stage is called action. In this stage, people receive got changed their dysfunctional conduct at to the lowest degree 1 24-hour interval as well as no to a greater extent than than 180 days. People inwards the activeness stage receive got lay into practise the innovation developed inwards the training phase. They are consciously choosing novel behaviors, beingness confronted amongst challenges to the novel behaviors, as well as consequently gaining novel insight as well as developing novel skills. For example, the woman raise who no longer uses corporal penalty tells her social worker, "In the finally few weeks of non hitting, I've realized that it is easier to hitting than to non hit, as well as when I am tired as well as the kids are driving me crazy, it takes all I got to non hitting them. I really appreciate my 1 friend who doesn't spank – she's so expert to live around." People inwards the Action stage are enthusiastic as well as motivated. When social piece of work students as well as most of Earth think nigh what it would live similar to produce therapy, they normally think of working amongst people inwards the activeness phase. Prochaska as well as Prochaska (2009) noted that most handling programs are built some the activeness phase, fifty-fifty though only a pocket-sized percent of clients are really inwards action. (Story nigh meaning adult woman as well as how slow it was).Assessment
Social workers should heed for statements that betoken both an acknowledgement of a prior occupation as well as novel behaviors. Again amongst the kid welfare example, a manful soul raise mightiness say, "I'm doing something nigh the behaviors that got me involved amongst kid welfare inwards the inaugural off place."Intervention
Intervention inwards the activeness stage includes a lot of verbal reinforcement as well as supporting the person's belief that he or she tin sustain the change. In motivational interviewing this is called "supporting self-efficacy." You want to seat specific behaviors that your customer has changed as well as connect them amongst the changes you're seeing inwards their life. For example, if a woman raise has changed her parenting vogue as well as you lot notice that her children are responding improve as a result, you lot tin brand encouraging statements that explicitly back upwardly the mother's powerfulness to alter her conduct as well as acquire the results she wants as a final result of the change. For example, you lot could say something like, "I notice that during supervised visitation you lot are using to a greater extent than encouraging statements amongst your kids, as well as are less probable to withdraw when they start fighting. I've also noticed that ever since you've been doing that your kids receive got brought upwardly the dependent of coming dwelling theater to a greater extent than often, as well as are to a greater extent than excited nigh the theater unit of measurement getting dorsum together. They also seem truly happy when you lot pay them compliments rather than ignoring them. All of these things suggest that as difficult as it is to raise differently, you're really making a lot of changes as well as they seem to live making a big divergence for your children as well as your family."Maintenance
Characteristics
The 5th stage is called maintenance. In this stage, people receive got been engaged inwards the novel conduct for at to the lowest degree vi months as well as are committed to maintaining the novel behavior.Assessment
You know your customer is inwards maintenance when they study at that topographic point is no occupation as well as are able to pull how their electrical current conduct is dissimilar from their yesteryear dysfunctional behavior.Intervention
Intervention at the maintenance stage looks dissimilar than at the previous iv stages. You volition in all likelihood live coming together less frequently. Your conversations volition revolve some how your customer is sustaining their commitment to the novel behavior. You volition beak nigh how he or she mightiness grapple amongst a relapse as well as ways to avoid relapse. Clients inwards this stage of alter tend to live confident nigh their powerfulness to maintain the change. You tin assist your customer to seat when they receive got acquire overconfident, as well as consequently mightiness lay themselves inwards a seat to relapse. As an example, I was working amongst a gay human inwards his belatedly 40s who reported 12 months of sobriety. I knew this customer was inwards maintenance because he described his yesteryear behaviors as well as distinguished them from his behaviors from the yesteryear year. He was confident nigh his powerfulness to rest sober, but had decided to move into therapy as he started to acquire dorsum into the dating scene. He was looking for a committed human relationship that was supportive of his drug as well as alcohol gratuitous lifestyle. In our inaugural off session he said that he could think of 3 places he could detect a partner, as well as each seat presented some challenge to his sobriety: bars as well as clubs, the AA coming together he'd been attending, as well as online. We talked nigh how frequent contact amongst his AA sponsor would live 1 way of demonstrating commitment to sobriety, as good as a source of back upwardly spell stepping out into situations that mightiness trigger a relapse. For example, nosotros talked nigh what he would produce if he met a human online who suggested they acquire together for a drink. He was clear that he wouldn't gulp as well as was confident that he could live some someone who was drinking, but had concerns nigh how his sobriety mightiness aspect to his date. So, nosotros addressed situations that mightiness trigger him to want to drink, including the want to accept the border off of coming together someone new, the want to adjust to social expectations, as well as the fearfulness of non beingness able to perform sexually sober. We came upwardly amongst a innovation that included back upwardly yesteryear his sponsor, self-affirming statements, as well as an honest beak amongst his date. I also had him pull what his life was similar prior to becoming sober, including losing his undertaking as well as beingness homeless for a period. I contrasted that amongst his electrical current province of affairs as well as emphasized how easily he could lose it all. Since he was inwards maintenance, emphasizing these differences served to reinforce his commitment to sobriety as well as added a sense of urgency to the plan.Relapse
There is an unofficial 6th stage – relapse. This is the "falling off the wagon" stage. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 relapse is defined as resuming the quondam behaviors. So, you lot receive got to engage inwards novel a behavior, which way you lot are inwards activeness or maintenance, earlier you lot tin "relapse" into quondam behaviors. The longer someone is inwards maintenance, the to a greater extent than devastating relapse tin live to the soul as well as those some him or her. People who relapse often experience disappointed as well as frustrated. Watching a customer move through relapse tin live painful for the provider. But, as I mentioned before, it shouldn't live unexpected. Relapse is considered the unofficial 6th stage of alter for a argue – it occurs rattling frequently. So, you lot shouldn't balance on your honour as well as hold off for your customer to relapse. But, when it happens, don't over react as well as brand the province of affairs worse.Intervention
There are a duo of specific areas to address when intervening amongst someone inwards the Relapse stage. The inaugural off is to detect out what triggered the relapse. Have your customer pull the instant he or she engaged inwards the quondam behavior, as well as and so piece of work backward to detect out how he or she got to that point. Next, you lot tin review your client's motivation for engaging inwards novel behaviors as well as seat what barriers be that mightiness preclude your customer from "getting dorsum on the wagon." If you lot receive got been working amongst your customer for a while, you lot tin review the motivations identified during piece of work inwards a prior stage. Listen for novel motivators. Sometimes people inwards relapse gain insight into why they produce what they produce as well as are able to come upwardly up amongst novel motivators as good as barriers. The 3rd expanse to address is your client's coping strategies. Clearly his or her coping strategies were insufficient to maintain the change, so you'll want to assist him or her seat as well as implement novel coping strategies. Since your customer is probable to live feeling similar a failure for relapsing, admit his or her feelings as well as and so reframe the relapse as an chance to acquire as well as acquire stronger. You tin say something like, "I realize you lot experience similar a failure, as well as I empathize why. But I want to suggest that perhaps this relapse is a wake-up telephone outcry upwardly to some of the problems amongst the strategies you've been using as well as an chance to create them as well as improve on them." The customer I talked nigh who presented inwards maintenance had a relapse during our treatment. Although our sessions had gone good inwards the beginning, he had been unsuccessful finding a partner. One of the people he met online had invited him to move sailing. He ended upwardly drinking a vino cooler on the boat. Although he stopped later on 1 drink, he felt horrible nigh himself as well as his recovery. He was so ashamed that he had non yet called his sponsor. When nosotros talked nigh what happened he said that he had been out on the boat all 24-hour interval without eating, that he was so grateful to receive got some companionship that he threw caution to the wind, as well as that he was exhausted from beingness inwards the Sun all day. He said that he had non taken aid of his basic needs as well as was Hungry, Angry, Lonely as well as Tired –the iv states that brand upwardly the AA acronym, HALT. He fifty-fifty said that he thinks his experience had taught him that at that topographic point was a 5th basic demand that hadn't been met – that he was horny. He laughed as well as said that HALT should live renamed HHALT. Our intervention addressed his novel insight into how he could maintain sobriety as well as some of the unexpected challenges of improving his romantic life. We came upwardly amongst a novel innovation as well as he implemented it. Given that he had a relapse, 1 time he engaged inwards the novel plan, what stage was he in? If you lot said, Action, you'd live right. So, our sessions changed focus somewhat to address the needs of people inwards the Action phase.Conclusion
To review, the stages of alter model is a way of thinking nigh how someone goes nigh changing his or her behavior. The stages of alter model assumes that alter takes time, that at that topographic point are mutual tasks inwards each stage, as well as that yesteryear tailoring your intervention to tally the stage of change, you lot volition live to a greater extent than successful inwards helping your customer to brand lasting change. The stages of alter model is the fundamental create of the broader Transtheoretical Model, which also includes Processes of Change as well as ways to evaluate change.There are 5 official stages as well as 1 unofficial stage. The Precontemplation stage is the "ignorance is bliss" stage. People inwards this stage don't watch a occupation as well as consequently are non interested inwards changing their behavior. The 2nd stage is Contemplation. People inwards this stage are "on the fence:" they admit a problem, but are non certain it the benefits of alter outweigh the benefits of staying the same. The 3rd stage is Preparation. People inwards this stage watch a occupation as well as "testing the waters;" they taking pocket-sized steps towards change. The quaternary stage is Action. People inwards this stage receive got identified a innovation for changing the conduct as well as receive got started to implement it. The 5th stage is maintenance. People inwards this stage receive got been engaging inwards the novel conduct for at to the lowest degree vi months. The unofficial 6th stage is relapse. People inwards this stage receive got "fallen off the wagon" as well as are engaging inwards the quondam behaviors.
Critiques of the model
Like all pop models, the Stages of Change model has been dependent to numerous criticisms. In 2002 Julia Littel as well as colleagues published a review of 87 studies using the Stages of Change model as well as concluded that at that topographic point was no evidence to back upwardly assertion that at that topographic point are consistent stages of alter across a attain of situations, occupation behaviors, as well as populations. There is no conclusive evidence that alter occurs inwards stages, rather than as a continuous process. And finally, at that topographic point are no known studies that follow the progression through all 5 stages. Prochaska as well as Prochaska (2009) countered these criticisms, stating that it was misleading to evaluate the stages of alter model exterior of the broader TTM, which the admit has been dependent to far fewer studies.In 2004, Adams as well as White suggested 2 reasons why the stages of alter model may non live applicable to complex behaviors, such as those commonly presented yesteryear social service clients. 1) The model was developed some changing unmarried behaviors, such as smoking cessation, as well as does non clearly concern human relationship for changing multiple related behaviors, such as changing parenting styles. 2) Identifying the stage of alter depends almost solely on customer self-assessment, rather than standardized measures. How produce I know that my customer is inwards precontemplation? She tells me. If I inquire my customer if they receive got changed their parenting behavior, they mightiness answer "no," placing them inwards precontemplation, contemplation, or preparation. However, a parenting skills inventory mightiness suggest that changes receive got occurred inwards 1 area, but non another. Thus the determination that the customer is non inwards "action" is based on a global assessment of change, rather than accounting for dissimilar levels of alter within a to a greater extent than complex laid of behaviors. Although the developers of the model noted that the alter procedure is non linear (Prochaska & DiClemente, 1983), some studies receive got found that self-report statements tin seat people inwards dissimilar stages within a affair of days, as well as sometimes multiple stages at once.
Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 terminal regime notation nigh the stages of alter model. It is non the only model that has been developed for explaining how people alter behaviors. Conner as well as colleagues (2004) identified iv other proposed models, including the Health Action Process Approach (Schwarzer, 1992), the Precaution Adoption Process Model (Weinstein, 1988), Goal Achievement Theory (Bagozzi, 1992) as well as the Model of Action Phases (Gollwitzer, 1990; Heckhausen, 1991) that are similar to Prochaska as well as DiClemente's stages of alter model.
So, the stages of alter model, although dependent to criticism, remains a widely used model for agreement how people change, assessing a client's readiness for change, as well as developing programs as well as interventions that target alter behaviors.
--End--
APA (6th ed) citation for this podcast:
Singer, J. B. (Producer). (2009, Oct 10). Prochaska as well as DiClemente's Stages of Change Model for Social Workers [Episode 53]. Social Work Podcast [Audio podcast]. Retrieved from /search?q=MI3
Buat lebih berguna, kongsi:
